Decked Builder - Mobile Apps for MTG

Opinions wanted: old and new Decked Builder icons

05/15/2012

4 Comments

 
Hi all,

We would love to hear your opinions about the old and new Decked Builder icons. I have posted both of them below in their 512x512 size glory. We had to change the old icon due to Wizards coming down on us for trademark use of their five color wheel.

Do you prefer the old icon to the new one? If you don't like the new icon, why and how would you improve it?



The old icon below


The new icon below
 


Comments

hpp3
05/15/2012 21:20

I preferred the old one and was sad to see it go. Part of the reason was because nothing says Magic like the colour wheel (unfortunately, as it turns out). The other reason is that I find the old icon to be visually cleaner. I'm not a fan of the fancy textures in the new one.

Marek
05/16/2012 04:24

New icon is better IMO:)

Lee
05/22/2012 04:21

Older one is simpler, easier to recognize considering its size on the iphone

D
05/22/2012 21:15

The on was preferable. I don't care for the planeswalker symbol and actually never noticed it in the old one. I guess I just prefer simpler.


Comments are closed.